Catholic teaching states that God created human beings to enjoy Him forever in Heaven. This is often interpreted as meaning that humans will experience joy in God’s presence. Yet Christianity also teaches that it is sinful to desire Heaven merely for the sake of happiness. Desire for Heavenly bliss can be portrayed as self-centered rather than God-centered, emphasizing sacrifice over fulfillment. This creates a tension: Heaven is advertised as desirable, yet desiring it for personal happiness is considered morally suspect.
The alternative to eternal salvation is being eternally lost and punished in Hell.
Some critics have argued that certain sacramental practices do not in themselves bring salvation. [Be aware that Catholicism teaches that baptism and the other six sacraments make God live in you and this life can last forever.] And they question whether trusting solely in the blood of Jesus for the forgiveness of sins is effective. They worry that the Trinity and notion that Jesus is both God and man may mask idolatry - a grave sin. They suggest instead that religious and spiritual trust can be misplaced. From this perspective, they cast doubt on the resurrection of Jesus as the foundation for his role as intercessor and savior, claiming that these beliefs rest on uncertain or misinterpreted grounds. Pushing the argument further, they warn that faith itself can be presented as a deception, even describing it as a trick of Satan, or corrupt human nature, designed to give false assurance and ultimately lead people away from truth and toward everlasting destruction or condemnation rather than salvation.
St Paul himself admitted that this was a valid concern for he warned that we are hopelessly lost and deserve only pity if Jesus was not our resurrected saviour.
If suffering on Earth is necessary for moral growth, then the absence of suffering in Heaven would seem to eliminate the conditions under which virtues are developed. Courage, compassion, and self-sacrifice are meaningful only in the presence of suffering and temptation. If Heaven contains no suffering or sin, then these virtues would no longer be exercised. This raises the question of whether Heaven would be morally superior to Earth or morally stagnant.
Christianity often equates love with sacrifice for God. If love necessarily involves sacrifice, then eternal life with God would seem to require ongoing suffering. Theologians respond that the willingness to suffer is sufficient, even if suffering does not occur. However, if love requires action and proof, then the absence of sacrifice undermines this definition of love.
God is said to know the inner state of every soul perfectly, making external testing unnecessary. This raises further questions about why temptation and trials are permitted at all. If moral worth can be known without testing, then suffering appears unnecessary.
If God is the supreme good and the ultimate source of happiness, believers should naturally be drawn toward moral behavior. If they are not, this suggests either a failure in religious teaching or a failure in God’s self-revelation. In this sense, moral failures among believers could be seen as reflecting flaws in the religious system itself.
If all goodness is identified exclusively with God, then love of self and love of others becomes secondary or even problematic. This framework risks undermining healthy self-esteem and genuine interpersonal love. A system that discourages valuing one’s own happiness raises serious concerns about whether it can plausibly promise fulfillment in the afterlife.
Christianity promises eternal happiness through Jesus Christ. Critics argue that such promises cannot be verified and that claiming certainty about eternal outcomes exceeds what any human or prophet could legitimately know.
From a philosophical standpoint, it is not self-evident that being with God necessarily guarantees happiness or fulfillment. This assumes that God is the only possible source of goodness. However, one could argue that goodness does not logically depend on God’s existence, and that the absence of suffering could itself be considered good. For example, if there were nothing at all, not even God, it is good that there is nobody to suffer.
Many people imagine Heaven as a place of supreme happiness because they isolate the doctrine from its broader theological context, including doctrines of suffering, sacrifice, and eternal punishment. Christian theology defines Heaven as eternal union with God, the supreme good. While this may be described as the best possible state for human beings, what is “best” does not necessarily mean what is most pleasant.
Comparison is a scary thing. If you are happy in Heaven because of what the alternative is - that is not real happiness. It is relief.
BOOKS CONSULTED
A CATECHISM OF CHRISTIAN DOCTRINE, CTS, London, 1985
A HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY, VOL 6, PART II, KANT, Frederick Copleston SJ,
Doubleday/Image, New York 1964
AQUINAS, FC Copleston, Penguin Books, London, 1991
BEYOND GOOD AND EVIL, Friedrich Nietzsche, Penguin, London, 1990
BOOK OF COMMON PRAYER, Association for the Promotion of Christian Knowledge,
Dublin, 1960
CATECHISM OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH, Veritas, London, 1995
CHARITY, MEDITATIONS FOR A MONTH, Richard F Clarke SJ, Catholic Truth Society,
London, 1973
CHRISTIANITY FOR THE TOUGH-MINDED, Edited by John Warwick Montgomery, Bethany
Fellowship, Minnesota, 1973
CRISIS OF MORAL AUTHORITY, Don Cupitt, SCM Press, London, 1995
EVIDENCE THAT DEMANDS A VERDICT, VOL 1, Josh McDowell, Alpha, Scripture Press
Foundation, Bucks, 1995
ECUMENICAL JIHAD, Peter Kreeft, Ignatius Press, San Francisco, 1996
GOD IS NOT GREAT, THE CASE AGAINST RELIGION, Christopher Hitchens, Atlantic
Books, London, 2007
THE GREAT MEANS OF SALVATION AND OF PERFECTION, St Alphonsus De Ligouri,
Redemptorist Fathers, Brooklyn, 1988
HANDBOOK OF CHRISTIAN APOLOGETICS, Peter Kreeft and Ronald Tacelli, Monarch,
East Sussex, 1995
HONEST TO GOD, John AT Robinson, SCM, London, 1963
HOW DOES GOD LOVE ME? Radio Bible Class, Grand Rapids, Michigan, 1986
IN DEFENCE OF THE FAITH, Dave Hunt, Harvest House, Eugene, Oregon, 1996
MADAME GUYON, MARTYR OF THE HOLY SPIRIT, Phyllis Thompson, Hodder & Stoughton,
London, 1986
MORAL PHILOSOPHY, Joseph Rickaby SJ, Stonyhurst Philosophy Series, Longmans
Green and Co, London, 1912
NEW COLOUR PIETA, Divine Mercy Publications, Skerries, Co Dublin, 1994
OXFORD DICTIONARY OF PHILOSOPHY, Simon Blackburn, Oxford University Press,
Oxford, 1996
PRACTICAL ETHICS, Peter Singer, Cambridge University Press, England, 1994
PSYCHOLOGY, George A Miller, Penguin, London, 1991
RADIO REPLIES, 1, Frs Rumble & Carty, Radio Replies Press, St Paul, Minnesota,
1938
RADIO REPLIES, 2, Frs Rumble & Carty, Radio Replies Press, St Paul, Minnesota,
1940
RADIO REPLIES, 3, Frs Rumble & Carty, Radio Replies Press, St Paul, Minnesota,
1942
REASON AND BELIEF, Brand Blanschard, George Allen and Unwin Ltd, 1974
REASONS FOR HOPE, Ed Jeffrey A Mirus, Christendom College Press, Virginia, 1982
THE ATONEMENT: MYSTERY OF RECONCILIATION, Kevin McNamara, Archbishop of Dublin,
Veritas, Dublin, 1987
SINNERS IN THE HANDS OF AN ANGRY GOD, Jonathan Edwards, Sword of the Lord,
Murfreesboro, Tennessee, undated
THE BIBLE TELLS US SO, R B Kuiper, The Banner of Truth Trust, Edinburgh, 1978
THE BRIEF OF ST ANTHONY OF PADUA (Vol 44, No 4)
THE GREAT MEANS OF SALVATION AND OF PERFECTION, St Alphonsus De Ligouri,
Redemptorist Fathers, Brooklyn, 1988
THE IMITATION OF CHRIST, Thomas A Kempis, Translated by Ronald Knox and Michael
Oakley, Universe, Burns & Oates, London, 1963
THE LIFE OF ALL LIVING, Fulton J Sheen, Image Books, New York, 1979
THE NEW WALK, Captain Reginald Wallis, The Christian Press, Pembridge Villas,
England, undated
THE PRACTICE OF THE PRESENCE OF GOD, Brother Lawrence, Hodder & Stoughton,
London, 1981
THE PROBLEM OF PAIN, CS Lewis, Fontana, London, 1972
THE PUZZLE OF GOD, Peter Vardy, Collins, London, 1990
THE SATANIC BIBLE, Anton Szandor LaVey, Avon Books, New York, 1969
THE SPIRITUAL GUIDE, Michael Molinos, Christian Books, Gardiner Maine, 1982
THE STUDENT’S CATHOLIC DOCTRINE, Rev Charles Hart BA, Burns & Oates, London,
1961
UNBLIND FAITH, Michael J Langford, SCM, London, 1982